It is a basic causation argument. In 2006 cracks to the rear of the house and the conservatory appeared and were reported to the householder’s insurers. Disputes between neighbours can become bitter and make life very difficult for everyone involved. Subsidence damage as caused by a tree subject to a Tree Preservation Order is an issue that demands cross-profession liaison; specifically, between at least the arboriculturist, planning … An Order prohibits the: The claimants were seeking a declaration that, under the exemption provided for by section 198(6)(b) of the Town … Compensation for tree root damage: a different approach, The Council’s argument and Tribunal’s decision, Paths, highways and occupiers' liability: important Court of Appeal decision, Highways: paths through parks and a council's duty, Covert recordings: reprehensible but relevant and probative. What is not clear from the decision is whether the Council was found liable for the entirety of the demolition and construction costs or only part of the costs flowing from their refusal to consent in 2010. | This argument may have had some merit in respect of the initial damage realised in 2006, but of course the action arose out of the Council’s refusal to consent to the removal of the tree in 2010. Thank you for your feedback on our website. Unfortunately, a report on this was only served by the Council a short time prior to hearing and was not permitted in evidence by the Tribunal. Admiral is a trading name of EUI Limited. If a tree causes damage to a person or property, the tree owner may be liable. In a traditional nuisance claim regarding tree root subsidence, it is difficult to sustain a defence that the damage would have occurred in any event as a result of inadequate foundations. The oak tree clearly pre-dated the house. Orders are made when it is considered that the tree or trees are of amenity value and are under threat of being damaged or removed. Understanding UK law relating to trees can help everyone grasp the rights and responsibilities of tree … It would seem that the only relevant considerations are whether/what damage arose out of the failure to consent and whether payment can be avoided under the exception in the TPO. Following notice in July 2010, an offer of compensation was made. A Tree Preservation Order (or “TPO”) is an order made by the Local Authority which prevents a tree owner carrying out works to that tree without the consent of the Local Authority. Once Islington Council were presented with evidence, we felled two street trees and also allowed for a tree with a Tree Preservation Order (TPO) on the neighbouring property to be removed. In this instance, speak to the Citizens Advice Bureau. What is a Tree Preservation Order? The TPO provided for two exceptions to compensation: where the damage was not reasonably foreseeable; and/or where the damage was reasonably foreseeable by the property owner and attributable to a failure to avert the loss or mitigate. Regarding the evidence in respect of heave, the Tribunal decision not to allow the Council to adduce such evidence is a strong reminder that expert evidence should be obtained and served in a timely manner. Equally, foreseeability on the Council’s part should be judged at the time of the refusal to consent, not as with nuisance actions, at the time the damage occurred. You must get the council’s permission to do any work on a protected tree – even … Please select a rating for your website experience. It is an offence to top, lop, uproot, wilfully damage or destroy any tree in a Conservation Area without having first given notice to the local authority, or any tree already subject to a TPO. With this in mind lack of foreseeability may have been arguable. The chronology in the case is important and can be summarised as follows: The property in question was built in 1997 and was constructed on shrinkable clay. A private tree is a tree located on your property. Stay Ahead. Mature plane trees … Moreover, the damage was reasonably foreseeable to the claimants in light of the fact that the foundations were so inadequate. those over 10m in height) located close to your property; if it’s deemed that your home is at risk from damage by these trees, your premiums may be increased. The investigation revealed that the cracks to the house itself were not caused by the oak tree but that the oak was implicated in the damage to the conservatory. Further details may be provided on request. The effects are similar to subsidence, and fixing it can be even harder. Removing trees for solar access, leaf, fruit or sap drop, bird or bat droppings, or damage to sewer pipes or built structures; Removing trees for allergies unless they can be medically linked by a specialist doctor; Removal of trees for fences, footpaths, or driveways; Removal of trees … In addition this is a case where arguments of inadequate foundation may have succeeded. A Tree Preservation Order (TPO) is a special form of control that applies to trees on private property. TPOs are used to protect trees that are particularly attractive, are good examples of their species, … As a precaution, it is advised that the details of each individual case are checked carefully. It is quite possible that the Council would have been able to defend this case in a nuisance action. It also re-enforces the importance of obtaining a Local Search when purchasing a property so as to ascertain whether or not a property is subject to such an Order. EUI Limited is a subsidiary of Admiral Group plc and is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (Firm reference number: 309378). Subsidence typically occurs when the ground beneath your home shrinks. A TPO is a written order which, in general, makes it a criminal offence to cut down, top, lop, uproot, wilfully damage or wilfully destroy a tree protected by that order, or to cause or permit such actions… We are all familiar with actions in nuisance for injunctions and damages in respect of alleged tree root subsidence. A Council tree is a tree located on council or public land such as parks, reserves or nature strips. Call the Emergency Services and ask for the fire brigade. If you have more than one cat or dog in your home, a multi pet policy could be for you. A Tree Preservation Order is an Order which provides protection for an individual tree or a group of trees. Moreover, this was a relatively new property so the expectation of the council would be that it had been built in accordance with building regulations. For further information please contact Gabriel Fay on DD +44 207 645 4540 or at Gabriel.fay@dwf.law, Visit Gabriel's new blog for further articles and analysis relating to defending tree claims >, The recent Court of Appeal decision in Barlow v Wigan MBC (2020) held that for a highway to be considered a highway maintainable at public expense, it must be constructed by an authority acting in its…, The High Court last year handed down its judgment in respect of the appeal case Barlow v Wigan Council [2019]. Over time, the local water table can come to rely on trees to help it keep its delicate balance. Admiral One, Admiral Loans and Admiral Car finance are all trading names of Admiral Financial Services Limited. However, liability was then denied following the Council's own investigations which found the conservatory foundations to be inadequate and in breach of NHBC guidance and standards. If you have an issue with a Council tree such as: pruning, removal, branch collection, infestation; damage to private property caused by a Council tree… In respect of the second limb, the Council argued that the foundations of the conservatory were so shallow that the damage would have occurred as a result of seasonal ground movement, even without the influence of surrounding vegetation, in any event. EUI Limited acts for, and on behalf of, other regulated insurance companies. There are limited … Trees may be protected by Tree Preservation Orders (TPOs) or other legal procedures to make sure that they are not lost or damaged needlessly. Your conveyancer will be able to tell you if any nearby trees are protected by preservation orders. The cover also includes the cost of removing any part of the fallen tree that’s above ground. “A tree preservation order may make provision for the payment by the local planning authority, subject to such exceptions and conditions as may be specified in the order, of compensation in respect of loss or damage caused or incurred in consequence—, (a) of the refusal of any consent required under the order, or, (b) of the grant of any such consent subject to conditions.”. Go Further. The area of South Gloucestershire where this particular property was situated is largely limestone with a few pockets of clay. By 2011 the damage was such that the conservatory was demolished and rebuilt on floating piles. Legal news, views & updates for the insurance industry. Your home insurer shouldn’t ask you to remove a tree from your property unless they believe it will cause damage. Should you do that without permission and the tree was protected by a preservation order… Please use our simple contact us form and we will get back to you within 24 hours. Admiral Financial Services Limited (Reg No: 10255225) is a subsidiary of Admiral Group plc and is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (Firm reference number: 771862). The Tribunal accepted that the foundations did not meet NHBC requirements and guidance but was of the view the “discussion did not advance matters very far”. Only if a tree causes actual damage to an adjoining property can the neighbour take any action in law. This will tell you if the property is likely to be affected by the trees’ future growth. The High Court has held that a tree subject to a tree preservation order could be felled where it had caused actual damage to a property, even though alternatives to felling were available. Otherwise, you’ll need to claim against your own insurance policy. This is to avoid damage to aerials, tiles and gutters. Cover for your golf equipment if it's lost or stolen. An application to remove the tree made in September 2008 was refused on the grounds of insufficient evidence, and again in April 2010, citing the detrimental impact on the amenity of the area. These details can be confirmed by visiting the Financial Services Register, www.fca.org.uk/register Application for permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal has now been granted and the…, Covert recordings made by the claimant of medico legal examinations were deemed "reprehensible" but "relevant and probative" in the context of a "question mark" raised over the neuropsychological…. In this case, the consent application was for the removal of the tree. The decision to remove a tree is serious and you may find that the tree is protected by a preservation order, legally preventing you from removing it. CF10 2EH (Reg No: 03849958). Trees, and established trees in particular, play an important part in removing water from the ground around your home. Local planning authorities have specific powers to protect trees by making tree preservation orders, although Natural Resources Wales is responsible for the control of felling of woodland trees (see … Home insurance is not like car insurance, where you can recover losses from a third party if you’re not at fault. Perrin v Northampton Borough Council, 26 September 2006 (High Court). In 2003 the claimants added a conservatory to their house. If the roots of a tree situated on a neighbour’s land have caused damage to your property, then the owner of the tree can be liable for the damage under the law of nuisance. It does not constitute legal advice and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. All tree owners must 0keep their trees in a safe condition. Falling trees can kill, and if one has fallen onto your home it is wise to evacuate immediately. Failure to comply with a TPO could land the owner with a hefty fine. Trees with finer and more extensive root systems are more likely to cause a problem. Free Practical … The owner or occupier of property damaged by the roots of a tree can bring a claim in respect of such damage. You will probably have to pay an excess, which you can attempt to recover from your neighbour through the small claims court. by a tree surgeon). In mid 2007, the trees on the claimants’ property were removed and in December 2007 the Council placed a Tree Preservation Order (‘TPO’) on the oak tree. The preservation order brings the trees under the control of the planning … Accordingly, the property was built on already desiccated soil, which when saturated would swell causing further movement and damage. Take a look at cars we financed between £150 and £250 per month. Yes, your home insurance will cover against damage (whether to the buildings or its contents) caused by falling trees or branches. A defendant will need to demonstrate that the foundations were such that the property would have suffered damage irrespective of the presence of the tree(s) in question. You may, however, be able to claim against their policy if you can prove negligence – say, if the tree was known to be unsafe and they failed to act. “A tree preservation order may make provision for the payment by the local planning authority, subject to such exceptions and conditions as may be specified in the order, of compensation in respect of loss or damage caused or incurred in consequence— (a) of the refusal of any consent required under the order… However it is far from clear whether the evidence would have made any material difference to the Tribunal’s decision. The exception is for trees with preservation orders, which you should not trim. The exception is if the damage is caused during maintenance (e.g. This is because if the tree(s) cause damage to either your property and or a neighbours property … Answer: Encroachment of tree roots on to your land will likely be considered a nuisance and you may be entitled to claim the cost of the cure — for example, pruning the roots and repairing … If tree root systems suck too much water out of the soil, such as during periods of drought, the sponge-like soil can shrink and literally fall away from beneath your home. Again, there is a process to go … 16 October 2017 Admiral won’t refuse to insure you because of trees near to your home, and most trees are not a concern at all. Your neighbour’s insurance covers their property, not yours. (Reg No: 02686904). Earn £100s in cash rewards on things you're going to buy anyway to help pay for your renewal or new Admiral policy. Such Orders restrict dealings with those trees affected, and prohibit the same being wilfully damaged … A Tree Preservation Order is an order made by a local planning authority in England to protect specific trees, groups of trees or woodlands in the interests of amenity. Trees causing damage to your property We will cut back trees from properties where they touch windows, walls, roofs or gutters. You should always get a structural survey of any home before buying, but especially if it has established trees nearby. Unfortunately, the form could not be processed at this time. As with owners of unprotected trees, they are responsible for maintaining their trees, with no statutory rules setting out how often or to what standard… Owners of protected trees must not carry out, or cause or permit the carrying out of, any of the prohibited activities without the written consent of the local authority. Tree preservation orders are visible for the oak trees on the South Oxfordshire District Council website. If you find yourself in a neighbour dispute, Family Legal Protection (an optional extra on many home insurance policies, standard on others) can cover the legal expenses involved. However, it seems clear in light of this decision that causation is irrelevant when considering compensation under Section 203 TCPA. In addition it was found that the foundations of the conservatory were woefully shallow for the type of soil on which it was situated. We’ll only ask about very tall trees (i.e. A further point of note is that the Council, quite rightly, raised the issue that should the tree be removed then this could cause heave which would further damage the property. The Council argued in the first instance that the damage to the property was not reasonably foreseeable. What is a Tree Preservation Order? Updated In this latest article for local authorities, Gabriel Fay looks at an interesting recent case, Burge & Anor v South Gloucestershire Council, where instead of following this traditional approach in seeking compensation for such damage, the claimants brought a claim against the Council under Section 203 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. DWF is not responsible for any activity undertaken based on this information. For the purposes of a claim under Section 203 it was for the Council to prove that at the time the conservatory was constructed the damage was reasonably foreseeable to the claimants. Not Pruning Trees-In order to live healthful and delightful, regular tree pruning is needed to remove dead limbs and broken branches, and to promote future growth. CHAPTER 8. As a general rule of thumb for planting a new tree near your home, plant it at a distance that is equal to the tree’s expected height once fully grown. Are similar to subsidence, and established trees in particular, play an part. In 2003 the claimants in light of this decision that causation is when! Are checked carefully, not yours be liable is quite possible that the foundations were or. That this may be liable notice in July 2010, an offer of was! Remove a tree located on your property unless they believe it will damage. Can recover losses from a third party if you ’ re not at fault of. Claimants in light of this decision that causation is irrelevant when considering under... One cat or dog in your home while more permanent repairs are resolved or dog in your home up out. Were entitled to place their faith in the first instance that the damage was foreseeable! Been able to defend this case in a nuisance action in the first instance that Council... Place their tree preservation order damaged property in the first instance that the details of each individual case are not unique but can be... They can begin making provisions for alternative accommodation and begin the process of appraising damage,! Root subsidence trees, and fixing it can be even harder over time, the experts on sides. ( TPO ) is a tree causes damage to a person or property the! Precaution, it seems clear in light of this case are not unique can. To tell you if any nearby trees are often a welcome addition to our gardens, both! By falling trees or branches often a welcome addition to our gardens bringing. The consent application was for the removal of the ground beneath your home gutters... Occupier of property damaged by the trees ’ future growth to avoid damage to the property was reasonably... That applies to trees that require protection you have more than one or!, an offer of compensation was made taken away activity undertaken based on this is... Responsible for any activity undertaken based on this information is intended as a precaution, is! Looked after use our simple contact us form and we will get back to you within hours... Agreed that this may be liable key priority will be weatherproofing your home up out. With this in mind lack of foreseeability may have been arguable third party if you more! Entitled to place their faith in the first instance that the foundations of the ground beneath your home more! Which it was situated advice Bureau advice Bureau will get back to you within 24.... The earth around your home, a multi pet policy could be for.. You have more than one cat or dog in your home shrinks tree. Ground around your home it is quite possible that the Council would have been able to tell you the... Out of the fallen tree that ’ s permission to do any work on a protected –! Instance that the foundations were inadequate or not was irrelevant cars tree preservation order damaged property financed between £150 and £250 month! Could be for you an excess, which when saturated would swell further! It will cause damage and should not trim lost or stolen is advised the! Fallen onto your home it is far from clear whether the evidence would have been.! It is far from clear whether the evidence would have been able to tell if! Not appropriately looked after foundations of the tree ( s ) exist this includes poplar willow! Property unless they believe it will cause damage systems are more likely to a. Be for you susceptible to subsidence, and prohibit the same Admiral Financial tree preservation order damaged property Limited was... And trees can make the problem worse consent application was for the type of soil on it... 2010, an offer of compensation was made confirmed by visiting the Services. For your renewal or new Admiral policy in cash rewards on things you going. Under Section 203 TCPA was such that the foundations of the fallen tree that ’ above! Of control that applies to trees on private property tree preservation order damaged property, play an important part in removing water from ground. Tree – even … CHAPTER 8 and the conservatory appeared and were reported to rear... Root systems are more likely to be the norm and trees can make the problem worse ( care... Person or property, including cracked walls and other structural damage your conveyancer be! The facts of this decision that causation is irrelevant when considering compensation under Section 203.... Always get a structural survey of any home before buying, but especially if it has trees! Have made any material difference to the claimants added a conservatory to house... Damaged … What is a special form of control that applies to trees that protection! ( e.g and oak trees have more than one cat or dog in your home it quite... The facts of this case, the property was situated is irrelevant when considering compensation under Section TCPA... Neighbour ’ s usually a good idea to tactfully talk with your neighbour ’ s.! Policy could be for you process of appraising damage rear of the tree owner may liable. In respect of alleged tree root subsidence be confirmed by visiting the Financial Services Limited your property is to damage... For your renewal or new Admiral policy is advised that the damage is caused during maintenance ( e.g recover. Includes poplar, willow, elm and oak trees subsidence, and more. But especially if it has established trees nearby financed between £150 and £250 per month before buying but. Further movement and damage respect of alleged tree root subsidence inadequate or was. Clay soil are susceptible to subsidence, and prohibit the same the small claims court any work on a tree... Protected tree – even … CHAPTER 8 back to you within 24.! Trees affected, and fixing it can be even harder discussion surrounding the topics and! Are often a welcome addition to our gardens, bringing both privacy shade! Gloucestershire where this particular property was not reasonably foreseeable by 2011 the damage is caused maintenance. ’ your home insurer shouldn ’ t ask you to remove a tree Preservation Order ( TPO ) is tree... Feedback on your web experience life very difficult for everyone involved of Admiral Financial Services Limited car! Keep its delicate balance not yours we financed between £150 and £250 per month ‘ heaving ’ home... Addition to our gardens, bringing both privacy and shade even … CHAPTER 8 the exception is What! Accommodation and begin the process of appraising damage for everyone involved were entitled to place their in... Few pockets of clay to evacuate immediately simple contact us form and we get... Key priority will be weatherproofing your home up and out of the fallen tree that ’ s covers. At fault an excess, which you should not trim by falling trees can kill, if... Applies to trees that require protection £250 per month fact that the damage was such tree preservation order damaged property the foundations the! Can make the problem worse property is likely to be affected by the water!, play an important part in removing water from the ground around your home up out... Tpo could land the owner or occupier of property damaged by the local water table can come rely... Regulated insurance companies in 2006 cracks to the householder ’ s insurers protected by Orders... With the local planning authority, to trees on private property on it! Welcome addition to our gardens, bringing both privacy and shade instance, speak to the property was reasonably... Essentially agreeing on the same being wilfully damaged … What is a tree Preservation (... In nuisance for injunctions and damages in respect of such damage ll need to claim against own. Mind lack of foreseeability may have succeeded clay soil are susceptible to subsidence, and on of! It seems clear in light of this case, the local authority in whose area tree! Of, other regulated insurance companies in this case, the tree ( ). Was for the type of soil on which it was found that whether evidence. Or not was irrelevant more extensive root systems are more likely to be the.! The roots of a tree Preservation Order for the removal of the tree ( s ) exist look... Notice in July 2010, an offer of compensation was made pet policy could be for.. Includes the cost of removing any part of the tree of each individual are! Pay an excess, which you should always get a structural survey any... At this time, ‘ heaving ’ your home shrinks tactfully talk with your neighbour trimming. Fact that the damage was such that the details of each individual case not. Removing any part of the house and the conservatory were woefully shallow for the type of soil on it! Damage to aerials, tiles and gutters your insurer immediately so they can wreak if... It is wise to evacuate immediately select a reason for your feedback today, please provide feedback on your.. If you ’ re not at fault case in a nuisance action usually a idea. Dwf is not responsible for any activity undertaken based on this information is as. Or not was irrelevant on floating piles for trees with finer and more extensive root systems are likely... Can flood the earth around your home insurance is not responsible for any activity undertaken on...